Packers-Lions-Safety Reversed

Lions get safety, lose it on official's call GREEN BAY, Wis. (AP) - The Detroit Lions thought they took the lead with a safety after two flags were thrown in the end zone in the fourth quarter of a 13-13 game against the Green Bay Packers on Sunday night. Turns out they had nothing at all. With the ball at the Packers 1, Brett Favre handed off to Samkon Gado, who ran right and was stopped in the end zone by linebacker Earl Holmes. As Gado was falling, he tossed the ball forward, and fullback Vonta Leach recovered. After a lengthy discussion by the officials, referee Mike Carey called intentional grounding on Gado for a safety and Detroit declined a holding penalty against right tackle Mark Tauscher. Packers coach Mike Sherman threw a red challenge flag, but the play was not reviewed. After another lengthy officials' conference, Carey returned to clarify that the throw by Gado was legal because he was outside of the pocket. ``It's a bad rule,'' Lions coach Dick Jauron said. ``When he explained the situation, a ball carrier is a passer when he's behind the line, and he can throw the ball, he has all the protection the quarterback has. If he's out of the pocket, he doesn't have to throw it near anybody, just to the line.'' The holding, which appeared to occur in the end zone on a television replay, was spotted inside the 1, and the Lions declined that penalty to bring up second down. Holmes, in an expletive-filled tirade, said he couldn't fathom the call. ``I have never seen nothing like that, never heard anything like that,'' Holmes said. ``There's no other way to tell me that was not a safety. You can't explain it. ... As soon as you question or you say something or you criticize the officials, you get a pink slip in your letter on Wednesday saying you did this or did that.'' NFL game observer Joe Rhein told The Associated Press that officials err on the side of caution in a situation with a flag thrown at the goal line. ``You don't want to give a team a cheap safety, so that's the thinking and the rationale behind the call,'' Rhein said. ``It's not reviewable, it's a judgment call. ``When in doubt, you don't want to give the cheap score, so that's where they start thinking. So now, where did the contact start, where did it wind up, that's all the judgment call of the officials.'' Carey did not comment on the call after the game. The sequence happened just after the Lions failed to score three times from the Packers 1, ending when Jeff Garcia couldn't sneak in on fourth down behind center Dominic Raiola and right guard Damien Woody with 7:07 left. Ryan Longwell kicked a field goal with 9:43 left in overtime and the Packers won 16-13. ``It shouldn't have came down to the officials,'' Lions receiver Roy Williams said. ``We should have punched that ball in and should have won this game.'' Green Bay Packers - Detroit Lions Goals Total 1 2 3 OT Shootout Green Bay Packers 16 Detroit Lions 13

 

Vikings-Lions

Vikings 21, Lions 16 DETROIT (AP) - Brad Johnson heaved a pass, pumped his fist and shouted with joy. The Minnesota Vikings are back - and Johnson is, too. Johnson threw two touchdowns, including an 80-yard pass to Koren Robinson that fired up the 37-year-old quarterback, and the Vikings held on to beat the Detroit Lions 21-16 Sunday. Minnesota's mess is becoming a distant memory. Detroit's is getting worse. The Vikings (7-5) have won five straight, salvaging their season after a bad start and the now infamous boat party. ``We've gotten ourselves out of a deep, deep hole,'' Johnson said. ``We're back in the ballgame, with four games left.'' Detroit (4- has lost five of six and didn't seem to be sparked by Dick Jauron in his debut as interim coach. In just six weeks, the Lions have gone from sharing the division lead to being mathematically eliminated from the race. Fed-up fans booed quarterback Jeff Garcia throughout the game, and directed their anger toward team president Matt Millen during much of the second half. ``Man, this is supposed to be our home stadium,'' said receiver Roy Williams, shaking his head. ``This felt like a road game.'' The Vikings appeared to be in control leading by 15 early in the third quarter after Michael Bennett's second TD, but the Lions rallied before losing their eighth straight in the series. Artose Pinner scored on a 6-yard run to make it 21-16 with 7:38 left after cornerback Brian Williams had an interception return for a score negated by a penalty. The Lions got the ball back at their 7 with 2:46 left after Paul Edinger - punting in place of injured Chris Kluwe - made a low, bouncing kick. Detroit drove to midfield before Garcia's up-for-grabs lob was intercepted by leaping safety Corey Chavous at Minnesota's 2 with 52 seconds left. ``I was glad we got back on the field because in those situations, you want an opportunity to make a play,'' Chavous said. The Lions led once - briefly. After Jason Hanson kicked a field goal on the opening drive, Johnson needed only one play to put the Vikings ahead with his long pass to Robinson. Johnson, who was 17-for-23 for a season-high 256 yards, is 5-0 since starting in place of the injured Daunte Culpepper. ``He's throwing it on time and he's throwing it precise,'' Robinson said. ``He's like Greg Maddux.'' Johnson has thrown eight TDs and just two interceptions after Culpepper had twice as many interceptions (12) as TDs (six) before having season-ending surgery on his right knee. Bennett had 79 yards rushing and a 7-yard TD, and caught a 5-yard TD to give the Vikings a 21-6 lead in the third quarter. Robinson caught four passes for 148 yards, surpassing his previous season total, and a TD. The loudest cheers at Ford Field came when a fan held a ``Fire Millen'' sign behind Minnesota's bench in the third quarter. Security scurried to take the sign away and more messages like it, but ``Fire Mil-len!'' chants could not be stopped. One fan amused the crowd as he ran from section to section, dodging security, holding up an anti-Millen sign. ``That was crazy stuff,'' said Edinger, whose game-winning, season-ending kick while playing for Chicago led to Millen's hiring. The Lions are an NFL-worst 20-56 since Millen took over the franchise in 2001. Garcia, who was cheered as Joey Harrington's backup, was booed regularly as Jauron's-picked starter and the rest of his teammates didn't escape the wrath of the crowd. ``We worked on that,'' Minnesota coach Mike Tice joked. ``We talked about getting the crowd to boo them early.'' Garcia finished 17-of-35 for 126 yards and an interception. ``We don't have the confidence in each other that we need to make plays,'' Garcia said. A play after Hanson's 45-yard field goal gave Detroit its only lead, Johnson lofted a perfect pass to Robinson, who simply ran past cornerback R.W. McQuarters for the score. ``We put that play in on Thursday. We knew it was coming,'' Robinson said. ``They said that they wanted to go at R.W. McQuarters, and he happened to line up on me.'' It was Minnesota's longest play of the year, and was Johnson's longest pass since 1996. ``What a great throw from Brad. He's having hernia surgery tomorrow,'' Tice joked. ``He threw that thing as far as he could throw it.'' When Garcia threw a pass at Williams' feet on the ensuing possession, the crowd chanted ``Jo-ey! Jo-ey!'' in a humorous moment because those same fans have jeered Harrington throughout his career. Notes Detroit WR Charles Rogers, the second pick overall in 2003, was inactive despite being healthy and RB Kevin Jones (thigh) also did not play. ... Kluwe and RB Mewelde Moore injured ankles during the game. ... Detroit LBs Boss Bailey (ankle) and Nate Wayne (ankle) and FS Jon McGraw (shoulder) were injured. ... Culpepper attended the game. Minnesota Vikings - Detroit Lions Goals   &n bsp;   &nb sp;   &nbs p;     ;  Total 1 2 3 OT Shootout Minnesota Vikings  21 Detroit Lions    & nbsp;    16